Preferred equity plays are on the rise, but whats the catch?
As more sponsors opt for preferred equity over subordinate debt, some may figure out the kinks the hard way
Such investments have become a critical source of financing for New York real estate projects in recent years. (Credit: iStock)
For developer Ian Bruce Eichner, who famously lost his Cosmopolitan hotel project in Las Vegas during the financial crisis, investing in real estate has been something of a tightrope act.
When Eichner bet on Manhattans luxury condo market with his 83-unit Flatiron project at the peak of the cycle, he turned to preferred equity players Dune Real Estate Partners and Fortress Investment Group both known for seeking out high returns. And after a drawn-out legal battle with both firms, henarrowly escapedlosing the development last year after landing a $167.5 million first mortgage from Madison Realty Capital using the unsold portion of the 60-story tower as collateral.
The move raised more than a few eyebrows. Its no secret, after all, that Madison has foreclosed on a handful of borrowers who got in over their heads, including the infamous East Village landlord Raphael Toledano.
In the rising world of preferred equity, that 11th hour rescue could be a harbinger of things to come for more than just Eichner.
Such investments, which take a front seat to an investors down payment when it comes to the payback pecking order, have become a critical source of financing for New York real estate projects in recent years. As the market recovery extends to extra innings, a growing number of sponsors are opting for preferred equity over subordinate debt to give themselves more of a cushion, according to those who negotiate financing for a living.
Anthony Orso, head of Newmark Knight Franks capital markets team, called it an easier way for owners to take some chips off the table and not be in a position where they overleverage their properties.
Steve Kohn, who leads Cushman & Wakefields structured finance team, echoed that point, noting that it may be a less expensive way to raise capital than refinancing the senior mortgage at a higher level especially when the senior lender wants to impose a prepayment penalty.
But others say preferred equity could lead to messy situations for some developers in the case of a downturn.
Unlike common equity from a developer and outside investors, preferred equity typically comes with fixed scheduled payments and returns that can run as high as 15 percent. Those terms come with their own pitfalls, which could wind up at the heart of some crumbling deals in New York City, said real estate attorney Edward Mermelstein.
Cracks are already showing with the oversupply of luxury condos and the same could occur in the office and retail markets, as spaces go unrented, he added.
The rise of preferred equity also coincides with a slowdown in EB-5 funding, which many developers had turned to after the crisis. A lot of the capital provided through the federal visa program will need to be replaced in the coming years, adding additional costs and complications to some real estate projects.
Today, its hard to raise any type of equity, said Mermelstein, who compared New Yorks real estate market to 2009 and argued that very few projects make sense.
Many of these projects need to be refinanced, and theres no ability to do so, he added.
In filling the so-called capital stack for construction projects and acquisitions, preferred equity typically falls in thegray area betweencommon equity and senior debt. In cases where theres a large gap between the two, it can become the deciding factor in a deal.
One of the biggest benefits, sources say, is that if revenue falls short of pro-forma estimates, a projects primary sponsor can retain a stake as a limited partner with limited upside, in a worst-case scenario. A mezzanine lender, on the other hand, can foreclose and seize an asset leaving the majority owner with nothing.
Its probably easier to do a preferred equity structure than your typical joint venture, said Michael Campbell, the new CEO of the Carlton Group, which brokers debt and equity deals for borrowers.
Though preferred equity has many of the same characteristics as junior debt, payments can be delayed until its most fortuitous for the equity holder in control of the asset. With a large condo project, for example, returns can be postponed until units start selling, according to those in the business. And in some cases, the capital can sit in reserve only to be tapped if a project runs into problems.
Those flexible terms can allow for negotiations that are virtually unheard of with traditional bank loans and even nonbank debt deals.
At Gary Barnetts 95-story Central Park Tower,$235 millionof preferred equity came from an unnamed hedge fund that has the option to convert its investment into condo apartments once the projects completed. That deal carries a fixed interest rate of 11 percent until December 2021, according to documents filed with the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange in January 2018.
The 179-unit tower, which has a projected sellout of $4 billion, will become the tallest residential building in the city when its completed, and the first to try to sell 20 units at $60 million and up.
Barnetts Extell Development and joint-venture partner Shanghai Municipal Investment cobbled together a $1 billion-plus financing package for the tower in the final hours of 2017. In addition to the preferred equity and a $900 million loan from a group of banks led by JPMorgan Chase, funds for the project are coming from foreign conglomerates, Israeli bondholders and the luxury department store chain Nordstrom, which is opening a new location in the towers base, the TASE fillings show.
A spokesperson for Extell declined to comment.
Daniel Berman, a real estate attorney with Kramer Levin, said theres less confidence in 2019 that big projects are going to gush money, making all investors happy, while some senior lenders may impose restrictions blocking subordinate debt which preferred equity can be a way around.
He referred to it as savior capital that makes a deal happen.
But even with the protections that preferred equity offers, its a little bit funky, and the strings attached can create issues for developers, Berman added. The problem in many cases is that by bringing in preferred equity, a developer takes on investors that may compete for control of the project should trouble arise.
Mermelstein said hes seeing newly created funds that are looking to acquire distressed projects at cents on the dollar. Having preferred equity instead of mezzanine debt wont protect the primary sponsor when push comes to shove, he added, noting that a lot of new developments are hitting brick walls.
In the citys luxury condo market, for example, the volume of new development sales tumbled nearly 40 percent in the first quarter of the year, compared to the same period in 2018, according to a Douglas Elliman report from April.
In the case of Eichners project at 45 East 22nd Street, the developer had sued his preferred equity partners, alleging they pushed him to the brink of default by interfering with his efforts to refinance the project.
Eichner declined to talk about the projects financing and representatives for Dune and Fortress would not comment either.
But Josh Zegen, one of Madisons three managing principals, said his firms loan smoothed over tension between the preferred equity providers and Eichners Continuum Company. Since then, he added, the condo project has sold very well, with about a third of the 24 units that were on the market at the time either closed or under contract. His companys loan has now been substantially paid down, Zegen noted.
Madison has also taken preferred equity stakes in other projects, according to Zegen, including a $90 million investment in Michael Stern and Kevin Maloneys Steinway Tower at111 West 57th Street.
Condo units that are complete or nearing completion have a pricing advantage over product that is still in heavy construction, according to Zegen. Theres been a capitulation on the sellers side, he said. If we want to move inventory, theres got to be pricing adjustments.
Craig Solomon, CEO of the real estate investment firm Square Mile Capital, said hes found steady demand for preferred equity in recent years and that his company looks for returns in the mid-teens on most of those deals.
Since 2013, Square Mile has injected nearly $1.5 billion of preferred equity into 22 assets in New York, Chicago and other markets with a combined project value of about $5 billion, according to the company. Those deals include Simon Baron Developments 43-story Alta tower in Long Island City, which Square Mile invested $138.5 million in last fall.
As the recovery reaches the 10-year mark, Solomon noted, those kinds of deals have become a central theme of Square Miles investment funds.
We strive to provide solutions up and down the capital stack, he told TRD by email. Preferred equity has become a growing and very successful component of that strategy.
Others that have made preferred equity investments in notable New York projects include Eyal Ofers Global Holdings Group, which recently put $52 million into Rockefeller Groups NoMad condo project at 30 East 29th Street. Global Holdings also invested$100 millionof preferred equity in 25 Kent, Toby Moskovits and Rubenstein Partners 500,000-square-foot office project in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. The recently completed building has yet to announce its first tenant.
A spokesperson for Global Holdings said preferred equity allows the firm to structure its capital to match a project and sponsors needs in ways that most funds cannot, while a spokesperson for Rubenstein called it a standard investment structure and another affirmation of confidence in 25 Kent and the Brooklyn market.
Representatives for Moskovitss Heritage Equity Partners did not return requests for comment.
I have a feeling that its more by necessity rather than by choice that people take the preferred equity. David Eyzenberg, Eyzenberg & Company
But David Eyzenberg, who runs a boutique advisory firm specializing in debt, equity and ground lease deals, said developers often have to make tough decisions when it comes to financing their projects.
I have a feeling that its more by necessity rather than by choice that people take the preferred equity, he said.
Update: This story was updated to include a statement from Rubenstein and to clarify that Madisons loan on Eichners 45 East 22nd Street project was a first mortgage.
Tags:bruce eichnerDevelopmentgary barnettReal Estate Finance
Heres what the $20M-$30M NYC investment sales market looked like last week
Can Edge-on-Hudson become a game changer for Sleepy Hollow?
After years on the market, Zaha Hadid-designed Related penthouse takes another big price cut
They are frozen: Cuomo says rent regulation is being held up by Senate politics
Rudy Giuliani and wife list Palm Beach condo amid nasty divorce
talks shop with the developers behind Hudson Yards
We are having some technical difficulties. Try again later.