You are using an older browser version. Please use asupported versionfor the best MSN experience.

One of the most hated tax breaks in America just wont die

One of private equity and hedge fund managers most prized tax breaks is again in politicians cross hairs, but Democrats would need to sweep the 2020 election if they want to pull the trigger to end the option.

President Donald Trump said in May that he wanted to increase taxes on carried interest, a major form of compensation for hedge fund and private equity managers. Several leading Democratic presidential candidates, including former Vice President Joe Biden and Sens. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren, also have said they want to end the break.

Yet there are a couple of reasons the carried interest tax break, despite bipartisan opposition, isnt dead yet. Most Republicans, and even some Democrats, oppose killing a tax option that investment firms have successfully argued creates jobs. And eliminating the break wouldnt actually raise all that much money.

Partnerships such as private-equity, venture capital and hedge funds typically get compensated in two ways. They charge an annual management fee, as well as a performance fee, which can be about 20% of gains, depending on the fund. For tax purposes, the performance fee is treated as a capital gain, meaning that it gets hit by a top rate of 23.8%, rather than ordinary income, where rates can reach as high as 37%.

Various proposals to tax carried interest as ordinary income have been estimated to raise between $3 billion and $16 billion over a decade, depending on the particulars of each plan. Thats a drop in the bucket for federal spending, meaning that it has limited value as a money-raiser.

As a political scalp, its still something very hot for Democrats, but no Republicans are going to vote for a tax increase, said Stephen Myrow, managing partner of Beacon Policy Advisors in Washington. Its an uphill battle unless Democrats control everything.

The preferred tax treatment is a frequent target on the campaign trail as a way to pay for other priorities. Democratic candidate Amy Klobuchar, a Minnesota senator, said in a CNBC interview in May that eliminating the loophole could help pay for infrastructure. Kamala Harris, a California senator, in March similarly cited carried interest when asked in an NPR interview about her proposed tax rebate to lower-income households.

And the current crop of candidates isnt the first to put the break in their sights.

Former Democratic Representative Sander Levin of Michigan first introduced the Carried Interest Fairness Act of 2012 that would have largely ended the options favorable tax treatment. It was never approved by the Republican-led Ways and Means Committee. The Carried Interest Fairness Act of 2015 didnt fare any better, nor did the Carried Interest Fairness Act of 2017.

The Carried Interest Fairness Act of 2019, now sponsored by New Jersey Democrat Bill Pascrell, has 28 cosponsors, fewer than Levin had four years ago.

Mr. Trump campaigned on giving regular Americans a fair shake. His repeated support for closing this egregious loophole combined with Americans desiring real reform gives me genuine hope for passage this Congress, Pascrell said in a statement issued through a spokesman.

Historically, performance fees received the more-favorable tax treatment as long as a fund held the investment for at least a year, but the 2017 tax law increased the minimum holding period to three years. That hit some faster-trading hedge funds hard, but was less painful for private-equity and venture-capital funds, which tend to have longer holding periods.

Related video: Trump lobbied for tax loopholes in the 1990s that he now calls sport(provided by ABC News)

Socialism gains popularity in America, particularly among women, poll finds

A new survey shows that the idea of socialism is gaining traction in the U.S., especially among women. Veuers Justin Kircher has the story.

Trump does not see Fed Chair Powell as a friend, Jim Cramer says

CNBCs Jim Cramer weighs in on President Trumps feelings toward Fed Chair Jerome Powell when it comes to trade negotiations and the economy.

New York City seizes 46 ice cream trucks in crackdown

New York Citys Operation Meltdown seized 46 ice cream trucks after it said operators were hiding behind shell corporations to avoid paying traffic fines.

Trump lobbied for tax loopholes in the 1990s that he now calls sport

Trump lobbied for tax loopholes in the 1990s that he now calls sport

Socialism gains popularity in America, particularly among women, poll finds

Trump does not see Fed Chair Powell as a friend, Jim Cramer says

New York City seizes 46 ice cream trucks in crackdown

Scientists created a plastic thats infinitely recyclable

Total misstep or brilliant strategy? Politicians weigh in on Trumps tariff threat

Chinese entrepreneurs take on rural German town

China exports rise despite trade tensions with US

FCC gives phone companies the power to block robocalls

Homeowners turn to steel-frame houses for fireproofing

Pfizer had clues its drug could prevent Alzheimers. What happened?

Los Angeles: A city with 58,000 homeless and one house on the market for $500M

Private-equity magnates such as Blackstones Stephen Schwarzman, who is also a Trump adviser, have become protective of a break that helped make them billionaires. When President Barack Obama tried to close the loophole, Schwarzman reportedly likened it to Hitler invading Poland. He later apologized for the comparison.

For investment firms, it could have been worse. As the 2017 tax law was being written, Gary Cohn, then the White House national economic adviser, said the break should be eliminated. Ultimately, Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and some congressional Republicans fought for a compromise: Instead of taxing all carried interest as ordinary income, the threshold for taxing it as a capital gain would rise to three years from one year.

In a Fox News interview in May, Trump said hed still like to end the benefit and claimed that he traded keeping the loophole open in the 2017 legislation in exchange for a lower corporate tax rate. But in fact, raising the tax rate for carried interest would have raised more revenue in the tax bill, making it easier to lower corporate rates.

Analysts note that the tax treatment of carried interest doesnt have a large effect on the federal budget either way, making the change a strong political talking point without a real fiscal impact.

It certainly seems to be a likely target given the current environment. That being said, it is clearly not going to be much of a revenue-raiser, said Don Snyder, a tax lobbyist for Federal Policy Group in Washington.

Changing the treatment of carried interest also carries significant policy hurdles, Snyder said. For one, taxing all partnership gains the same way would encourage short-term trading, since hedge funds would no longer have a tax incentive to hold an investment for the long term, he said.

Trade associations that support keeping the break say that eliminating it could reduce investments in companies and kill jobs. The American Investment Council, a trade association for private-equity firms, releases an annualstudycalculating private-equity investment by congressional district.

Raising taxes on carried interest capital gains will destroy jobs, decrease investment, and discourage entrepreneurship across America, the groups president, Drew Maloney said in a statement.